• Immigration
  • Lexington Ave
    Down Town
    East Village
    MidTown West
    MidTown East
    Upper West
    Upper East
    Jackson Heights
    Long Island
    Staten Island

    Bengali Sweet Shop Hicksville Review

    Bengali Sweet Shop
    343 South Broadway
    Hicksville, NY 11801

    Other NYC Indian/Pakistani Restaurants
    Bengali Sweet Hicksville image © NYIndia.us

    Bengali Sweet Shop Hicksville Review: A Punishment

    A meal or takeout at some Long Island Indian restaurants is nothing short of a punishment.

    Here is the depressing account of one of my punishments at a Long Island Indian restaurant.

    The other day after shopping for Indian grocery at Patel Brothers on Broadway, I stopped by at Bengali Sweet Shop vegetarian restaurant to pick up lunch and some snacks and sweets.

    What attracted me to the restaurant was the huge sign advertising a $4.95 vegetarian thali.

    When I walked into Bengali Sweet Shop around 1PM, the restaurant was quiet with just three diners.

    After a quick glance at the menu, I placed my order for the $4.95 vegetarian thali. I also added some sweets and Pakora snacks.

    Bengali Sweet Shop thali comes with a choice of two curries, Dal, Indian bread, Pappad, pickle and Yogurt.

    I selected Alu Baingan Curry and Mutter Paneer curries from the food counter.

    As promised, the lunch thali came with Dal, rice with green peas seasoning, one Paratha, Pappad, pickle and plain Yogurt.

    Here is my take on Bengali Sweet Shop's lunch thali starting with Alu Baingan Curry:

    Vegetarian Thali

    Alu Baingan curry included three huge pieces each of potato and eggplant.

    It was obscenely spicy and badly lacking in the right proportion of spices and salt.

    Needless to say, I did not relish it one bit. Also the huge potato pieces left me scratching my head as to whether Bengali Sweet Shop's kitchen was unaware of mashing and slicing.

    Bengali Sweet Shop Thali image © NYIndia.us
    Lunch Thali

    Disappointed with the awful Alu Eggplant curry, I moved on to the second curry - Mutter Paneer.

    Mutter Panner was nothing but boiled green peas with some fried Paneer coated with chilli powder thrown into it.

    There was too little gravy and Paneeer cubes were red chilli powder hot.

    Also, the Mutter Paneer included just three small pieces of Paneer cubes.

    Dal was a complete opposite of Alu Baingan and Mutter Paneer curries.

    It was a bland disaster and did not come with any flavor or seasoning.

    Bengali Sweet Shop Dal was nothing but finely boiled lentils bereft of any flavor.

    In my opinion, an Indian restaurant that can't get the humble Dal right is unlikely to get other dishes right.

    Paratha and Rice

    White rice with green peas was alright. But it's really hard to mess that one up.

    Pappad was crisp.

    Paratha was big and soft.

    Bengali Sweet Shop Thali image © NYIndia.us

    But in the absence of edible curry sides, I could not really eat the Paratha or white rice.

    Pickle was the mixed vegetable pickle variety with a slight vinegar taste. It was definitely not in the class of Andhra Pickles but not bad.

    Vexed with the bad quality of curries and bland Dal, I moved on to Yogurt hoping to mix it with white rice and eat it along with the pickles.

    But sometimes in life, when it rains it pours.

    Alas, Bengali Sweet Shop could not get even the humble Yogurt right. It was too milky and not set properly.

    Ambiance and Service

    As you enter Bengali Sweet Shop, you have tables on the right, sweets counter on the left by the wall, and food counter and kitchen in the rear.

    I was greeted with a curt question by an Indian waitress "What do you want to order". Taken aback by the rude tone, I meekly mumbled thali and sweets.

    The takeout lunch thali was packed in a styrofoam box but no plastic spoons or forks, plates or napkins were included with the order.

    Also the packaging was bad and the gravy from Dal and curries leaked all over the plastic bag and soiled the styrofoam box.

    Bengali Sweet Shop Rating

    All in all, my Bengali Sweet Shop lunch takeout was a disaster. I may not revisit it even if they reduce the thali price to 99-cents.

    Based on my experience, Bengali Sweet Shop thali is not worth it even if you get it free. - © NYIndia.us

    Adyar A. Bhavan
    Anjappar NYC
    Ayurveda Cafe
    Bengali Sweet
    Bengal Tiger
    Biryani Cart
    Bombay Chat
    Bombay Fast
    Brick Lane
    Bukhara Grill
    Chennai Dosas
    Copper Chimney
    Curry Dream
    Darbar Grill
    Delhi Heights
    Dosa Delight
    Dosa Garden
    Dosa Hutt
    Ganesh Temple
    Ganesh Canteen
    Gourmet Sweets
    Gourmet Sweets
    Hot Clay Oven
    House of Dosas
    Indian Taj
    Indian Taj 2
    Indus Valley
    Jackson Diner
    Jackson Diner
    Joy Curry
    Kailash Parbat
    Kashmir Cuisine
    Khaabar Baari
    Madras Mahal
    Maharaja Sweets
    Chilli & Curry
    New Hot Breads
    NY Dosas
    Paradise Biryani
    Punjabi Deli
    Punjabi Tadka
    Royal Tangra
    Salaam Bombay
    Saravanaa Bhavan
    Shake Shack
    Spice Symphony
    Tangra Masala
    Tawa Tandoor
    Tiffin Wallah
    Trader Joe's NYC